Gold Migration Lawyers has closed. Our team is here to support their former clients. Get a FREE Consultation
Need help? Our lawyers and migration agents are available 7 days a week to assist.
Family & Parent Visas
Other Visas
Need help? We are available to speak to you 7 days a weekRead More
Need help? Talk to us, we are available 7 days!
Need help? We offer support in your language.
도움이 필요하세요? 한국어 지원이 제공됩니다.
お困りですか？日本語での対応可能です。
请問需要帮助吗？我们可以提供中文服务。
¿Necesitas ayuda con tu visa? Podemos ayudarte en español.
Tại đây chúng tôi có hỗ trợ tiếng Việt.
1300 150 745
Contact
2025 Telstra Best of Business Awards Nominee
Open 7 days
1300 150 745
Protection Visa Subclass 866: ART Appeal Success
.jpg)
Overview
An Indonesian national engaged Australian Migration Lawyers following the refusal of their Protection (subclass 866) visa application by the Department. The primary application, lodged in August 2024, had relied entirely on a political opinion claim relating to the Free Papua Movement, which the Department found lacked credibility and subsequently refused in January 2025.
Deep cultural stigma and intense personal anxiety had initially prevented the client from disclosing the true basis of their fear. Upon entering the merits review stage at the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART), the client disclosed to our team that they are a homosexual man who faces a well-founded fear of persecution if returned to Indonesia. AML took over representation at the ART stage, tasked with the complex challenge of completely reframing the case strategy and overcoming the significant credibility hurdles caused by the late disclosure of these claims.
Migration law services
Our legal team, led by Senior Associate Walt Calis, executed a comprehensive restructuring of the case presentation upon being engaged in August 2025. Recognising the delicacy of shifting from a discredited political claim to a sexual orientation claim, we prioritised building a transparent, supportive rapport with the client to understand their story fully.
Annalise conducted exhaustive country research to compile highly detailed submissions, filed in November 2025 - outlining the objective legal and societal perils faced by LGBTQIA+ individuals in Indonesia. Walt formulated a precise legal framework addressing the psychological and cultural reasons behind the client's delayed disclosure. He then thoroughly prepared the client for the emotional rigour of the Tribunal environment and provided expert oral advocacy during the ART hearing in April 2026, ensuring the client's genuine voice was clearly articulated and legally protected.
Outcome
In April 2026, just eight months after AML was engaged to prepare and advance the new claims, the Administrative Review Tribunal successfully set aside the Department’s original refusal. The matter was remitted with the explicit direction that the applicant satisfies the refugee criterion under section 36(2)(a) of the Migration Act.
The Tribunal Member fully accepted the client's identity as a homosexual man and agreed that he would face a real chance of persecution in Indonesia. Significantly, the Tribunal Member extended specific praise during the hearing for the exceptional quality and depth of the country submissions prepared by Annalise, which proved decisive in establishing credibility and securing a successful remittance.
"Taking over a complex matter at the ART stage always demands a meticulously reframed strategy, especially when navigating sensitive claims that a client was initially too fearful to disclose due to cultural stigma. Our primary focus was prioritising a supportive environment where the client felt safe enough to share his true narrative, allowing us to build a robust, evidence-backed case. Being able to call him and deliver this life-changing Tribunal decision on his actual birthday and hearing him say it was the absolute best present he could have ever hoped for was an incredibly profound and rewarding moment for our entire team." - Walt Calis, Senior Associate
The successful Administrative Review Tribunal decision notice, remitting the matter to the Department with a positive direction.
Facing visa challenges? Let us help you navigate the complexities of Australian migration law.
Contact us today for a consultation
See more visa success stories
Explore more of our visa success stories to see how Australian Migration Lawyers has helped clients achieve their immigration goals. From complex cases to straightforward applications, our expert team has delivered successful outcomes across a range of visa types.
Meet your Australian Migration Lawyers
Get to know the dedicated professionals behind Australian Migration Lawyers, committed to guiding you through every step of the immigration process. Our experienced team combines legal expertise with a personalised approach to help you achieve the best possible outcome.
.jpg)
%20(1).webp)
%20(1).webp)
.jpg)
%20(1)%20(1).webp)
%20(1).webp)
%20(1)%20(1).webp)
%20(1).webp)
%20(1).webp)
%20(1).webp)
%20(3).jpg)
%20(1).webp)
%20(1).webp)
%20(7).jpg)
.jpg)
Claim your free consultation!*
Tell us a little about your situation, and one of our migration lawyers will contact you as soon as possible.
Leaving without permanent residency?
Our experienced migration lawyers are here to help —risk-free. Ask about our No Visa, No Fee options and we'll guide you through every step of your journey.
No Visa, No Fee T's and C's apply
